The American Papist has a poll - Which US Archbishop should be named a Cardinal?
I picked Abp. Burke of St. Louis. But your mileage may vary. I would have picked Bp. Tobin if he was an Archbishop, but then, I'm only in a diocese (not an archdiocese), and Bp. Tobin is the best we've had in Providence in a long time - so we gotta keep the good Bishop here.